arrow_back Back to SMM 2026

SMM 2026 · Round 9 · Board 5

FM Aurelio Colmenares (SUI, 2310) – FM Jonas Wyss (SUI, 2255)

Date
11 October 2026
Result
0-1
Opening
Caro-Kann Defence, Exchange Variation (B13)
Time control
90 minutes for 40 moves, then 30 minutes, plus 30 seconds per move
Loading game

Analysis

The game in detail

FM Aurelio Colmenares (SUI, 2310) vs FM Jonas Wyss (SUI, 2255) · 0-1

Board 5, Genève vs ASK Réti · Caro-Kann Defence, Exchange Variation (B13) · 90 minutes for 40 moves, then 30 minutes, plus 30 seconds per move

By Bogner AI Coach AI Coach . This analysis was written by a Bogner Chess AI coach.

Replay the game on Lichess

Board five, Genève against ASK Réti, round nine and the last of the season, played in Geneva like round eight the day before. Across the board sits Aurelio Colmenares, FIDE Master, 2310, fifty-five points higher on the list. After seven rounds Réti stood fourth in the table and Genève seventh, and this is the final team match of the year: half a point from board five against the higher-rated man is what the other seven boards may count on. Jonas Wyss has Black.

On move ten White was suddenly a pawn worse off, after a move Colmenares had thought about for seventeen minutes. Between move 11 and move 17 Wyss handed that pawn back in four quiet moves, not one of which looks like an error. The position was level again with 6:32 on the clock for White and 27:18 for Black, and in that position Colmenares went wrong twice in a row.

The Exchange Variation, and twenty minutes for 9.Bb5

is the Exchange Variation, and it promises White very little. After the structure is fixed, and anybody who wants something out of it has to look for it on a wing. Wyss puts the bishop out with before the pawn goes to e6, which is the order this position asks for, and with and he brings the other bishop to the diagonal that looks at d4. costs a fifth of a pawn, kept the position level; costs nothing.

What moves in this opening is mostly the clock. Colmenares needs eleven minutes ten for and twenty minutes forty-eight for , and after nine moves it reads 33:17 for him against 55:38 for Wyss. is not a bad move, the position stays level after , and that is the move eighty-eight players in a hundred make here. A shade more came from , where Black collects the pawn on d4.

Twenty minutes for a developing move in a position where nothing can be forced are twenty minutes missing later on. The question in an opening like this one is not which move is best but which plan you want at all: White has only the push on the queenside here, and he could have found that in five.

FM Aurelio Colmenares (SUI, 2310)

FM Jonas Wyss (SUI, 2255)

After 9.Bb5, Black to move. The bishop pins the knight on c6 to the king, and White has used fifty-six minutes for nine moves, Black thirty-four.

10.b4, and White is a pawn worse off

kept the position level. is a wing pawn move played while the king is not yet safe, and it costs about a pawn: . White then has pawns on f3 and h3, his king in the middle and a centre Black has opened; in the main line he castles long. Colmenares spent seventeen minutes on the move.

is the move, and Wyss took five minutes forty-two over it. Fifty-nine players in a hundred castle here, thirty-four play , and both give away most of what has just appeared: holds a third of a pawn, four fifths, a whole one. The bishop goes where it prepares the exchange on f3, and that exchange is the reason for everything that follows, because after gxf3 the white king has no g-pawn in front of it.

After the clocks read 9:43 for White against 50:26 for Black. From here the fifty-five rating points stop mattering: a man a pawn worse off with ten minutes has to find every move himself, and nobody finds thirty of them. A push on the wing before castling is not a plan, it is a tempo the opponent gets back in the centre.

FM Aurelio Colmenares (SUI, 2310)

FM Jonas Wyss (SUI, 2255)

After 10.b4, Black to move. The white king is still in the middle, and 10...Be4 does not appear in the list of moves played here.

11...O-O and 12...Nxc6: the pawn goes in four moves

costs a third of a pawn, and it is the move you play with fifty minutes against ten: king safe, let the opponent solve the problems. In practical terms that is easy to understand. Objectively the break in the centre does not wait: first removes the knight that guards d4 and opens the centre only after gxf3 has wrecked the white kingside; in that line White castles long.

is the choice of sixty-eight players in a hundred here, and at four tenths of a pawn it costs more than did. The move was , and the reason is the order: after White has to deal with that bishop, which is attacking g2 and the queen on d1, and his own bishop on c6 cannot escape in the meantime. Only then does Black decide what recaptures on c6, and that is the pawn, because the knight is better placed on e7.

: Wyss does nothing wrong in this stretch, and are the best moves of their positions, and after move sixteen he still stands close to half a pawn better. A whole pawn has become half of one, and it went not on one move but on two that both look sensible. When the opponent offers an exchange, the question is not whether you take but in which order: the exchange that can walk away from you is the one that comes first.

FM Aurelio Colmenares (SUI, 2310)

FM Jonas Wyss (SUI, 2255)

After 12.Bxc6, Black to move. Three answers: take with the knight, take with the pawn, or trade on f3 first.

16...Kh8, 17...g5, and 18.Ne2 was not played

cost thirteen minutes forty-three, the longest think of the game, and it is a waiting move that costs a quarter of a pawn. The piece that needs a job is the bishop on f6, and gives it one: from d6 the bishop looks at the pawn on f4 and gets the diagonal towards h2. After the clocks read 28:45 against 7:12.

is the move that finally spends the half pawn. kept it; after the position is level. In practical terms it is the most awkward question you can put to an opponent with six minutes, because the white king has had no g-pawn since and has been sitting behind the gap since . Both things are true at once: the move worked, and objectively it was an error.

was the only move that holds, and it stands a full pawn clear of everything else. Colmenares had 6:32, used one minute six and played , which costs a pawn and no more: after Black is one pawn better. What was played is after three minutes forty-seven, and that is the move that decided the game: the bishop on e3 was the piece covering f2 and g1. came after nine seconds. When lines open in front of your own king, the next exchange is rarely the answer; the king move was.

FM Aurelio Colmenares (SUI, 2310)

FM Jonas Wyss (SUI, 2255)

After 18...Bxg5, White to move with 5:56 on the clock. 19.Kh2 keeps the deficit at one pawn, 19.Bxg5 loses the game.

The conversion: 22...Qxf2, not 22...Qh4

and take less than five minutes together, and there is not much to weigh up: the open g-file belongs to Black, the knight on f5 is immovable, and f2 cannot be held for long. There is nothing between and . , played in seven seconds, gives f2 away at once.

Seventeen players in a hundred reach for here, and that move lets the win go: , and the position is level. Wyss took one minute sixteen and played , the move that takes the pawn and puts the queen on the square from which it takes every flight square off the white king. After that everything is forced.

: all four rooks are off, Black is a pawn up, and the only thing in front of the white king is the pawn on h3, with forty-eight seconds on the clock. is the last try, the pawn two squares from promoting. ends it: after White has no queen left, and the pawn is caught by checks, . Fifty-one players in a hundred check first here, , six in a hundred play straight away, and both of them win. In a winning position the move that takes pieces off the board is usually stronger than the move that gives check.

FM Aurelio Colmenares (SUI, 2310)

FM Jonas Wyss (SUI, 2255)

After 22.Ne2, Black to move. 22...Qh4 looks like an attack and is level, 22...Qxf2 wins.

Verdict

A full point with Black on board five, on the last day of the season, against a FIDE Master fifty-five points higher: that is more than the team could ask of this board. The first half belongs to the story too. After Wyss stood a pawn better, and with , , and the advantage was back at nothing by move seventeen, four moves of which each cost between a quarter and four tenths of a pawn and not one looks like an error. It is the third game of this event in which he stood clearly better, and is the same lesson as in round 7: the question is not whether you take but with what, and in which order. The second half he earned himself: and in thirty seconds between them, rather than the attacking move one player in six picks there, and from move 20 to the end not a single move that gives anything away. Colmenares did not lose this game on one move: a man who needs fifty-six minutes for nine moves has six left at the moment that counts, and is not a move six minutes necessarily finds. For the team this is a full point on the closing day; for Wyss it is the game in which he never let the opponent back in after the slip, and that is exactly what you want to see on board five.

Moves

0-1

Was this analysis useful?