Analysis
The game in detail
IM Yohan Benitah (FRA, 2314) vs IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229) · 1-0
Board 7, Genève vs ASK Réti · Queen’s Gambit Declined, Three Knights Variation (D37) · 90 minutes for 40 moves, then 30 minutes, plus 30 seconds per move
By Bogner AI Coach AI Coach . This analysis was written by a Bogner Chess AI coach.
Replay the game on LichessBoard seven, Genève against ASK Réti, round nine and the last of the season, all five matches in one hall in Geneva. Across the board sits Yohan Benitah, International Master, 2314, eighty-five points higher on the list. Genève are the higher number on six of the eight boards, four and a half board points win the match, and Christian Maier has Black. On this board against that number half a point is what the other seven may count on.
On move twenty-two the game was level, and the knight on e4 was the best piece on the board. Then Maier took on c5 with it, after forty-nine seconds, and from there he stood a good pawn worse. It is the second round in a row in which a level position against a clearly stronger opponent broke on a single capture.
A structure without theory, and the knight to h7
is a move the book knows, and it costs a fifth of a pawn: it waits where and do something in the centre. Benitah takes at once: . That fixes the structure, pawns on c6 and d5 against pawns on d4 and e3, and whoever wants something here has to push. is played by one player in fourteen at this level, is the usual move, and the difference is a sixth of a pawn, which is taste. The first ten moves cost Maier five minutes fifty-eight and Benitah fifteen minutes forty-one; after the clocks read 1:19:19 against 1:29:02.
costs fourteen minutes twenty-nine, with 1:11:25 left after the move, and it is a move almost nobody at this level plays. It cost a fifth of a pawn, and what paid for it was the clock. after nine minutes forty-eight costs a third of a pawn; was the move, asking the bishop on g5 the question, and it came one move later anyway. Benitah answers with his longest think, thirteen minutes fifty-seven on : the pawn supports the e5 square, where a knight will stand seven moves later.
On move fifteen the active move was on the board, and almost nobody finds it: , a knight for a bishop, material level, White a third of a pawn better, and the white pawns on g2 and g4 doubled. What was played is , and the knight that started out on d7 on move seven stands on h7 after three moves, looking at f8 and g5. After it Black stood a pawn worse. Then came the longest think of the game, twenty-four minutes eight on , with 29:10 left after the move, and the queen was back on the square she had left on move twelve. was half a pawn better: a pawn given, two pairs of pieces off the board. In a cramped position the move that puts a piece out of the way is rarely the move; the one to look for is the move that attacks something.
IM Yohan Benitah (FRA, 2314)
IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229)
18...Ne4, and White leaves the push alone
, and Maier puts the knight in the middle. is the best move, half a pawn ahead of everything else, and one player in ten at this level finds it. No white pawn can chase it from e4, the d-pawn stands on d4 and the f-pawn on f4, both past it, and White has to decide: takes the pawn and gives up both bishops for it.
Benitah took differently, , and there the choice was Maier’s: eighty-four players in a hundred recapture with the queen, the rook costs a quarter of a pawn. , and with Benitah supports the knight on c5, but leaves out : that would have taken the knight off the board before it settled on e4, and held a good half pawn. After the game was level. gave it back, a good three quarters of a pawn, and was the move, with the idea of facing the bishop on d3, which otherwise takes on e4 sooner or later.
That left White a good three quarters of a pawn better, and would have held it. What was played is , after fifty-eight seconds: a move that places a piece well and pushes nothing, and the game was level again. This is where the eighty-five points stopped mattering. Space is a matter of pawns: with more space, the move that pushes usually serves you better than the move that puts a piece on a pretty square.
IM Yohan Benitah (FRA, 2314)
IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229)
22...Nxc5, the move one player in three makes
The position was level when Maier, after forty-nine seconds, played and took the knight off e4. That is a tactical error. The knight Benitah would have given his bishop for on move twenty-one, Maier took off the square himself. After a pawn stands where the knight stood, and it works for White: it covers the d6 square, where the white knight lands on move twenty-nine, and with the pawn gone from b2 the b-file is open for the white rook that arrives on move thirty-three. Black stood a good pawn worse after it.
was the move, and it holds the game at level: , the white bishop is off the board and a knight stands on e4 again, where no pawn can chase it. The move order is not the point. The point is that the knight on e4 was the piece holding this position together, and that Maier traded it for a knight that a pawn replaces. That one player in three at this level takes the same way makes the move human, not correct: the knight on c5 was the piece in the way, and the reflex takes it.
Benitah calculated for six minutes fifty-eight before recapturing, and that deserves saying. arrived after eight seconds and costs nothing, and were just as good; the bishop leaves e6 before the push f5 can hit it. Before your best piece leaves its square, be clear about what will be standing on that square afterwards.
IM Yohan Benitah (FRA, 2314)
IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229)
26...dxe4 was the only move, 27...Qd5 was not
, and Maier puts the second knight on the square the first one left: . Benitah takes it at once, and is the only move, everything else costs two more pawns. A black pawn stands on e4 now instead of a knight, and the bishop on c8 is the piece that has not yet found a square.
puts the rook behind the g4 pawn, and the push g5 is the plan. after four minutes forty-eight costs three quarters of a pawn, and it is the move the position does not need: after the bishop has to go to e6 anyway, only a move later. was the move, because it brings into play the piece that has been waiting on c8 since move twenty-three, and because it prepares counterplay on the queenside: .
after one minute thirty-two costs another two thirds of a pawn and opens lines for the pieces White has; was the move. After Benitah then let something go himself: was worth three quarters of a pawn more than , which came after one minute fifty-four. When you stand worse you do not open the position, and when you stand better you would rather push the pawn than trade it.
IM Yohan Benitah (FRA, 2314)
IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229)
The queens off, and the rook to b6
was right and the best move with it: when you are two pawns worse, you take the queens off. Then came the one move of this phase that cost something, and it came in six seconds. attacks the rook on c4, and the rook goes where it wants to go: , , , and the pawn the open b-file has been pointing at since move twenty-three is gone. was the move, a full pawn better: the rook faces the knight on d6, and White has to attack the queenside from the front. A move that attacks a piece is a gift when the piece stands better on its new square.
From move thirty-five on Maier had less than five minutes, and Benitah never went under five: after it was 9:12 against 4:22. The clock decided nothing here. The game was decided on move twenty-two, when both of them still had more than twenty-six minutes. Maier reached the time control with 4:48, and with the thirty minutes that came after it he played on at 33:15 against 26:26 in a position a pawn down with the knight on d6.
Benitah took his time over it, moved the rook between f8 and g8 and only brought the king up with ; that is the clean way to win a position like this. Maier fought to the end, and , , which only one player in twenty plays, and were the best moves in the position. After two pawns were missing, after three, and against he resigned. From move thirty-three on there is nothing to hold against him.
IM Yohan Benitah (FRA, 2314)
IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229)
Verdict
On board seven against an International Master eighty-five points higher, Christian Maier did the job for twenty-one moves: a structure in which nobody knows anything by heart, never more than a good pawn behind, the move one player in ten finds, and after a level position, because Benitah left the push alone. He gave it away with one move. is a tactical error and not a question of move order: the knight on e4 was the piece holding the position, after a pawn stands there that hands d6 to the white knight and the b-file to the white rook, and would have held the game at level. That one player in three at this level takes the same way explains the move and does not excuse it; it is the same lesson as in round eight, this time eleven moves earlier. In practical terms it looked a little different: Benitah calculated for six minutes fifty-eight before recapturing, and he let something go twice, with and with ; from move twenty-three on he still had the easier position to play, and his clock was never the problem. Nor was Maier’s: the twenty-four minutes on were expensive, but the error fell in forty-nine seconds, with twenty-six minutes on the clock. Two sentences stay for the next game: you do not trade your best piece just because it can take something, and when you stand worse you do not open the position. For the team it is a zero on a board where half a point was budgeted; for Maier it is the game in which he held everything together for twenty-one moves against a stronger opponent and lost it in one move, and that hurts more than a game that was never open.
Moves
1-0
Was this analysis useful?