Analysis
The game in detail
GM Romain Edouard (2536) vs IM Evgeny Degtiarev (2358) · ½-½
Board 1, Genève vs ASK Réti · Zukertort Opening, Reversed Grünfeld (A08) · 90 minutes for 40 moves, then 30 minutes, plus 30 seconds per move
By Bogner AI Coach AI Coach . This analysis was written by a Bogner Chess AI coach.
Replay the game on LichessBoard one, Genève against ASK Réti, round nine and the last of the season, all five matches of the day in the same hall in Geneva. Across from Evgeny Degtiarev sits Romain Edouard, grandmaster, 2536, a hundred and seventy-eight points above him, and Degtiarev has Black. After seven rounds Réti are fourth with ten match points and Genève seventh with six, and on six of the eight boards Réti are the lower rated side; board one is the widest of those six gaps. Four and a half board points win the match, and no line-up counts on half of one from board one: whoever takes it takes work off the other seven boards.
It became a half point, after sixty-six moves. For forty-six of them the game never stood more than half a pawn out of balance, then a rook move by Degtiarev lost it and a pawn move by Edouard gave it back. This is the third grandmaster in three rounds and the widest rating gap of the three.
A pawn up and an hour less
: the queens are off on move seven and Black is a pawn up. The position is level all the same, because the pawn on c4 costs pieces that have to stay with it. attacks it at once, defends it, and that is the best move on the board; is a tenth of a pawn behind. It cost nineteen minutes forty, with 59:33 left after it, and almost nobody at this level finds it.
asks again, and is the only move that keeps the pawn: everything else is half a pawn worse. Black gives the bishop for the knight, White gets two pawns on the a-file, and c4 is still there. , and alone takes ten minutes.
goes onto the board after fifteen minutes four, with 21:21 left, and it is the move that gives the extra pawn back. Edouard collects it in four moves: . is the only move there, everything else costs more than a pawn; at the end material is level and Black has two pawns on the a-file, both of which fall in the endgame. would have kept the pawn and the balance, and the difference is about a third of a pawn. At Degtiarev’s level is the most common move, which makes it human and not correct: holding an extra pawn is not a matter of counting the defenders, it is a matter of asking whether one of them can be captured.
GM Romain Edouard (2536)
IM Evgeny Degtiarev (2358)
25.h4, and the only answer
After the board holds an endgame, rook and knight against rook and bishop, material level, Edouard about a third of a pawn better. is the best move, and then the king walks: .
gives away his third of a pawn; , and would have kept it. Practically it is still the best move on the board, because it asks a question almost everyone at this level answers wrongly. Nearly three quarters play here, and that costs more than two pawns: the white rook gets the h-file. costs a pawn, and the reason sits on the h-file: White has two passed pawns there and Black has no pawn left on it.
costs six minutes forty, with 11:07 left after it, and it is the one move that holds the position. , and of the three answers this is the only one without a passed pawn: each side has one pawn left on the wing, h4 against h7, and the open g-file belongs to both. Edouard tried it with and left it again with . In a pawn trade what counts is not how many pawns are left afterwards, it is which file opens and who gets a passed pawn out of it.
GM Romain Edouard (2536)
IM Evgeny Degtiarev (2358)
Under five minutes from move 29
, and alone costs nearly six minutes; it leaves 3:39 against 1:07:18, and from here to the time control Degtiarev plays under five minutes. , and the position is where it was; was a sixth of a pawn better, which is taste. Between move 26 and move 46 no black move loses more than that sixth.
goes onto the board after three minutes eleven, with 1:09 left, and and would have been just as good. with 51 seconds, with 1:04, with 1:28: White collects both pawns left over from , and Black is a pawn down with one minute against one hour.
makes the material level again, and the rook lands where it belongs: behind the passed pawn on a3. That pawn never moves again, and it is not captured until move 48. with 42 seconds, with 43, finally collects the pawn from move six, and brings the thirty minutes of the time control: 27:04. Nine moves between 33 and 41, never more than two minutes on the clock, and not one of them loses anything. An enemy passed pawn is stopped from behind: from there one move ties it down, and it does not have to be stopped again every move.
GM Romain Edouard (2536)
IM Evgeny Degtiarev (2358)
47...Rd3, a tactical error
, and Degtiarev takes fourteen minutes eighteen, with 13:21 left. Out of it comes , an eighth of a pawn behind and , which is taste. is also the move most players at this level pick, and three moves later it is still the right one. , and nothing is left on the board but rooks and pawns.
is a tactical error. The pawn on e4 cannot be held, not after either, only there White pays for it with the rook that has to chase the h-pawn, and the position stays level. and hold it just as well. changes nothing and spends exactly the move the pawn on h5 needed: after the white rook is on the fifth rank before the pawn is down the board, and White stands more than two pawns better.
Edouard played in seven seconds, and it was by far the best move: of the alternatives the best leaves half a pawn and the others leave nothing. He goes on cleanly from there, , and two pawns of advantage have become more than five. In those six moves Degtiarev played nothing that cost more than a tenth, there was simply nothing left to hold. In a rook ending a tempo is worth as much as a pawn: when your own passed pawn is the whole of your counterplay, it runs at once and not after a move that changes nothing.
GM Romain Edouard (2536)
IM Evgeny Degtiarev (2358)
54.f5 instead of 54.Ke4
would have won: the king walks towards the h-pawn, the rook steps in front of it, and the two white pawns simply stay where they are. wins the same way. What the position needed was a king move.
cost twelve minutes twenty, leaving 43:34 on the clock. It is not a time-trouble move, Edouard had the time and spent it right here. After nothing is left of those five pawns, because from onwards the white rook is allowed to do nothing but watch the h-pawn, and it does not get off the h-file again until move 66.
Degtiarev plays the rest on the increment. costs two minutes fifty-two and leaves 45 seconds, and the king goes where the white pawns are. After the passed pawn has become a queen and is gone in the same move. It was never meant as a queen: it pulled the white rook to h1, and the pawn on e4 fell on the way. , and the board holds two kings. A passed pawn is not there to become a queen; it is there to tie an enemy piece to itself.
GM Romain Edouard (2536)
IM Evgeny Degtiarev (2358)
Verdict
A half point on board one against a grandmaster rated a hundred and seventy-eight points higher, and not one the line-up had counted on. Both halves stay honest: was a tactical error, and after it the game was objectively lost, for six moves and by more than five pawns at move 53; Degtiarev did not win it back, Edouard gave it away with , after twelve minutes and with no time trouble. What belongs to him is the part before and the part after: , the one move that held the position and one almost nobody at this level takes; nine moves between 33 and 41 with never more than two minutes on the clock and not one of them losing anything; behind the passed pawn on a3; and from an endgame he played correctly on 45 seconds all the way to an empty board. For the second time in two rounds a grandmaster failed to find the one winning move against him, and both times Degtiarev had stood long enough for there to be one to find. The sentence to keep is the one from move 47: when your own passed pawn is the whole of your counterplay, it runs at once. For Degtiarev this is a half point out of a game that could not be held after move 47, and for Réti one of the four and a half that win the match.
Moves
½-½
Was this analysis useful?