arrow_back Back to SMM 2026

SMM 2026 · Round 9 · Board 4

IM David Pires Tavares Martins (2443) – GM Clovis Vernay (2461)

Date
11 October 2026
Result
1-0
Opening
Queen's Pawn Game, Accelerated London System (D00)
Time control
90 minutes for 40 moves, then 30 minutes, plus 30 seconds per move
Loading game

Analysis

The game in detail

IM David Pires Tavares Martins (2443) vs GM Clovis Vernay (2461) · 1-0

Board 4, Genève vs ASK Réti · Queen's Pawn Game, Accelerated London System (D00) · 90 minutes for 40 moves, then 30 minutes, plus 30 seconds per move

By Bogner AI Coach AI Coach . This analysis was written by a Bogner Chess AI coach.

Replay the game on Lichess

Board four, Genève against ASK Réti, round nine and the last of the season, all five matches of the round in one hall in Geneva. Across the board sits Clovis Vernay, grandmaster, 2461, eighteen rating points higher, and the third opponent in three rounds who is rated above Martins. Réti went into this final weekend fourth, Genève seventh. From board four against a grandmaster a half point is the number the other seven boards get to work with; four and a half out of eight wins the match.

It became a full point in twenty-four moves. It was built on move eleven, and on move twenty-one it was nearly gone again.

11.g4, the move almost nobody plays here

. Black gives up the bishop, White takes towards the centre with the h-pawn, and two things are on the board that carry the rest of the game: the open h-file and a second pawn on g3 that can run. Vernay paid for the opening in minutes, thirteen minutes eleven on and eight minutes fifty-nine on . After ten moves he had 32:35 against 1:19:31 for Martins.

, and now . At this level almost everybody reaches for here. is the best move in the position, and Martins played it in seventy seconds, with 1:18:51 left after it. The pawn wants g5 and then g6, and what Black has against it is called c5: is the best line of the position and the one that costs Black least.

Vernay thought for eight minutes thirty-nine and played . That was the second time c5 did not come: it was the first move of the position after , again after , and a third time after , where leaving it unplayed cost about a pawn and a half. In structures like this one c5 is not one move among several, it is the whole of the counterplay, and it hits the pawn on d4 while the white king is still in the middle. A break that gets postponed does not come later, it does not come at all.

GM Clovis Vernay (2461)

IM David Pires Tavares Martins (2443)

After 11.g4, Black to move. The pawn wants g5 and g6, the h-file is open, and the white king is still on e1.

14.gxf7+, the move nine out of ten play

. Vernay needed thirteen minutes fifty-three for and came out of it on 11:32. leaves the pawn on g6 where it is: the rook collects the pawn on h7, White is a pawn up, and the wedge on g6 keeps taking air from the black king.

Martins thought for two minutes three and played , the move nine out of ten play at this level. It is about two thirds of a pawn worse: the wedge is gone, the pawn count is level again, and after the black king stands in the middle, but it stands quietly. After , was the first move of the position for a third time; Vernay thought three minutes eight and played , which costs about a pawn and a half.

A far advanced pawn is usually worth more where it stands than the exchange it can buy. Before cashing it, count what it holds down in the opponent position and how much of that is left afterwards. Here it bought a check and a king move, and what was left was an equal number of pawns.

GM Clovis Vernay (2461)

IM David Pires Tavares Martins (2443)

Before 14.gxf7+, White to move. Black has just taken on c3, and the pawn on g6 stands between f7 and h7: cash it or leave it.

Nine minutes, then one and a half

Between move sixteen and move twenty the clock runs and the position holds. cost five minutes twenty-nine, with 1:08:27 left after it, and it is the slower of two good moves: was about three quarters of a pawn better. Vernay spent five minutes six on , and after he was down to 1:35.

and are both the best move in the position, and both do the same thing without forcing anything: the knight on f4 aims at g6 and h5, the bishop on e4 at g6 and c6. took Martins three minutes fifty-five, with 59:11 left, and after twenty moves the clocks read 59:07 against 2:26. Against an opponent in time trouble, the move that improves a piece beats the move that forces matters: it asks the same question again, and every repetition costs the other side seconds he does not have.

GM Clovis Vernay (2461)

IM David Pires Tavares Martins (2443)

After 19.Be4, Black to move with 1:57 on his clock against 59:11. Knight and bishop both aim at g6, the knight at h5 as well.

21.Qh3, a tactical error

was already a mistake, a pawn and a half worse than , and h3 was nearly a pawn better than g3 at that moment too. Then Vernay played , in thirteen seconds. The move attacks two things at once, the pawn on d4 and the knight on f4, and it is the hardest question anybody asked in this game.

Martins thought for sixteen minutes and one second, his longest think of the game, and played , with 43:36 left. That is a tactical error, and not a question of move order. On h3 the queen guards the knight on f4 only indirectly, through the knight on d7: takes the pawn back and leaves White clearly better. That guard hangs on a piece Black can defend himself in one move. , and two and a half pawns of advantage come down to a good one. The move was .

Vernay had 1:10 on his clock, thought for one minute forty-six and played . With that the mistake was handed straight back, and more than that: after White stood better than he had before . When a pawn attacks two pieces, the tension gets resolved before a third idea gets looked for. And a guard that runs through an enemy piece holds only as long as the opponent cannot defend that piece.

GM Clovis Vernay (2461)

IM David Pires Tavares Martins (2443)

Before 21.Qh3, White to move. The pawn on e5 attacks the pawn on d4 and the knight on f4, and the tension has to be resolved.

Twenty-four moves, one move left

cost five minutes ten, with 38:56 left, and it is the most expensive move of the game: was well over a pawn better, because from d3 the knight attacks the pawn on e5 and holds the square c5, while on e2 it props up the pawn on d4 and does nothing else. Vernay had 1:10, thought one minute three and played ; was about a pawn better for him. Taking back with cost two minutes thirty-four and a good pawn again: brings the knight into the game and keeps the e-file shut. After it is open, and the white king is on e1.

ended the game without being the worst move in the position: takes the king out of the open file and holds White to a pawn or so. attacks the queen on f6, and the only piece defending her is the king: any move that leaves her there loses her, for instance, queen for rook. So the queen has to move, and there is exactly one square: . Everything else loses on the spot, for instance. Vernay had 44 seconds, and there is no twenty-fourth move from him.

Against an opponent in time trouble the strongest move is not the sharpest one but the one that allows exactly one answer. is such a move: it costs nothing if the answer comes, and it wins at once if it does not.

GM Clovis Vernay (2461)

IM David Pires Tavares Martins (2443)

After 24.Rf3, Black to move with 44 seconds. The rook attacks the queen on f6, the only piece defending her is the king, and she has exactly one square.

Verdict

A full point on board four against a grandmaster rated eighteen points higher, in the final round of the season. The opening carried it: almost nobody at this level plays , and three times over c5 was the move Black needed and did not play. What came afterwards belongs in the same account: , after sixteen minutes, after five, after two and a half, four moves that between them handed the advantage back from a good three and a half pawns to a good one. Credit where it is due: Vernay found in thirteen seconds, the move that asked White the hardest question of the game, and he was still asking questions with under two minutes on his clock; that he missed the answer by one move every time belongs in the same line. The learning is the one that sat on the board for sixteen minutes: when a pawn attacks two pieces, resolve the tension first, and a guard that runs through an enemy piece is not a guard. Two and a half points from three rounds against three higher-rated opponents, and the question of who is actually defending the attacked piece had already decided round 7. For Réti it was a full point from board four instead of the half the other seven were allowed to count on, in the round the season ends in.

Moves

1-0

Was this analysis useful?