Analysis
The game in detail
IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229) vs FM Moritz Valentin Collin (SUI, 2418) · 0-1
Board 7, ASK Réti vs SG Riehen · Sicilian Defence, French Variation (B40) · 90 minutes for 40 moves, then 30 minutes, plus 30 seconds per move
By Bogner AI Coach AI Coach . This analysis was written by a Bogner Chess AI coach.
Replay the game on LichessBoard seven, ASK Réti against SG Riehen, round eight, played in Geneva, where all five matches of the round sit in the same hall that day. Riehen are second with twelve match points, Réti fourth with ten, and this is the direct duel between them. Across the board sits Moritz Valentin Collin, FIDE Master, 2418, a hundred and eighty-nine points higher on the list than Christian Maier, who has White. On board seven against that number half a point is what the team may count on, and what this board gives away, the other seven will not casually win back against Riehen.
For thirty-two moves Maier played exactly the game the job asks for. After thirty moves the position was level again. Then he took a pawn that was free for one move only.
The position of the game
White to move: what is the best move?
IM Christian Maier, White, against FM Moritz Valentin Collin in round 8 of the Swiss National League A. Collin has just attacked the knight on h3 with , his rooks are doubled on the e-file, and Maier has a good six minutes left to the time control. One move keeps the game going, every other move loses it.
FM Moritz Valentin Collin (SUI, 2418)
IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229)
Show the solution
The best move
takes the pawn that attacks the knight and leaves the knight where it is. That is the point: from h3 it covers f2 and g1, the two squares next to its own king. After White is a pawn up with the worse position, but he has a game.
What was played is , after forty-nine seconds. The knight steps away and gives up exactly those two squares: , and two moves later it is mate. The queen comes in on f2, the rook on g1.
Takeaway Moving an attacked piece away also moves away everything it was guarding. Check first whether the attacker can simply be taken.
A setup instead of a theory duel, and the question on move nine
is not a theory move, it is a decision against theory. Maier puts the whole setup up first with , and , and comes when it suits him. Against an opponent a hundred and eighty-nine points higher that is sensible: in this position nobody knows anything by heart.
The question of the opening is on the board on move nine. was the move, and four players in five at this level take that way: the pawn stays on d4, White keeps the centre occupied, and the push is answered by taking space, . What was played is , a quarter of a pawn less, and after Collin has the pawn pair on c6 and e5, the half-open b-file and not one bad piece.
is the push Black plays for in this structure, and after he stands a third of a pawn better. The first ten moves cost Maier nine minutes and Collin thirteen; after move ten the clocks read 1:25:59 against 1:21:58. With two ways to recapture, what decides is not which piece comes into play but which one holds the centre afterwards.
FM Moritz Valentin Collin (SUI, 2418)
IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229)
The bishop to a4, to b3, back to c2
costs fifteen minutes thirty-eight, the longest think of the game, and after it Maier has 58:53 on the clock. The move loses nothing, the bishop moves here all lie within a fifth of a pawn of each other. What Maier paid for it is the clock and the bishop: the bishop went to d2 one move later anyway, and a move earlier it would have gone there with a plan, , the knight gets clamped and White is a quarter of a pawn worse, no more than that.
was already the best move on move seventeen, which means back to the square of move 13. What was played is , a third of a pawn, then and , and came anyway, now as the clear best move, half a pawn ahead of everything else. In between comes , another quarter of a pawn. costs nothing but ten minutes twenty-eight, and after the knight has exactly one square: , because everything else costs two pawns, . after ten minutes nineteen then puts the queen on the square that would have been just as good on move twenty.
There is no blunder in this phase. There are two moves, and , costing a quarter to a third of a pawn each, and three thinks costing thirty-six minutes twenty-five between them: , , . Before move 15 Maier stood a third of a pawn worse, around move 21 a full pawn, and the clocks after move twenty read 38:55 against 39:43, which is level. A piece that returns to its own square has paid two moves for it and has shown the opponent on the way where to push.
FM Moritz Valentin Collin (SUI, 2418)
IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229)
Collin resolves the tension himself
From on, Maier plays ten moves with nothing wrong in them: , , , , . is the only move there that does not lose three pawns, and it arrives in eight seconds.
The one who gave it back is Collin. after three minutes ten costs a third of a pawn, because the exchange takes off exactly the bishop that needed four moves to find a square. after one minute thirty-eight costs the rest: before it Black stood half a pawn better, after the position is all but level, and keeps it there. was a fifth of a pawn better than , and at this point that is nothing.
Thirty moves, and the hundred and eighty-nine points are no longer on the board. After move thirty Maier has 20:10 and Collin 13:51, six minutes less. When you stand worse you play the moves that give nothing away and leave it to the opponent to decide when the tension drops; tension the opponent resolves himself is tension you no longer have to hold.
FM Moritz Valentin Collin (SUI, 2418)
IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229)
Three times the rook belonged on f1, then came 33.Qxh6
After move thirty White needs one move, and the rook belongs on f1 for it. holds the position at level, after fifty-four seconds costs a quarter of a pawn. One move later the same thing: , and the knight that has been standing on h3 doing nothing since move 21 comes back into the game. What was played is after four minutes thirty-nine, close to half a pawn.
after two minutes thirty-six, with 13:31 on the clock, is a tactical error. The pawn on h6 is free, but it is free for exactly one move. arrives after forty-four seconds, with 8:10 on the clock: the square is covered by the pawn on c4 that has stood there since move eighteen, and the rook on d1 has to take the knight. , a rook given for a knight, a black pawn on d3, and the extra pawn has turned into a deficit of more than two. would have held it at a good half pawn, even with Black collecting the pawn on b2 there.
This is not a question of move order and it is not an inaccuracy either: the move wins a pawn and loses the exchange. Collin saw it at once, and that deserves saying. Before winning a pawn the question is not whether the pawn is defended, it is which move the opponent has afterwards.
FM Moritz Valentin Collin (SUI, 2418)
IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229)
34.g4, the move Collin did not find, and 35.Nf4
was still the best move even then: give the rook for the knight, allow the pawn on d3, play on. after seven minutes seventeen, with 6:44 on the clock, costs another two pawns, and here Collin had the game in his hands: is worth more than four pawns, and after there is nothing left for White to hold. He calculated for five minutes and played , with 3:40 on the clock, and White was a good pawn worse again.
was the move that keeps the game alive: , a pawn up on the board and a pawn worse in the position, and that can be played. arrives after forty-nine seconds, with 6:25 on the clock, and loses on the spot to . After that it is mate, and from here on there is nothing to hold against Maier.
Both of them reached the time control. With at 2:02 Collin took the check that was in his hand instead of mating faster with ; mate it stayed either way. Maier spent three minutes fifty on and three minutes thirty-five on and had 1:19 left after it, Collin 1:08, and neither of them went under a minute. Against Maier resigned. In positions like that you count the opponent checks first: was on the board before was played.
FM Moritz Valentin Collin (SUI, 2418)
IM Christian Maier (GER, 2229)
Verdict
For thirty-two moves Christian Maier played the game board seven asks for: a setup instead of a theory duel, never worse than a good pawn, and after thirty moves a level position against a player a hundred and eighty-nine points higher. He gave it away in two moves. is a tactical error and not an inaccuracy in the move order: the pawn costs the exchange, was there immediately, and would have held the position. settled it, and the fact that Collin did not find the strongest continuation after five minutes of thought changes nothing about that; in that phase both of them had chances. The clock was not the reason, Maier never went under a minute and had 1:19 after move forty, and from move 33 on the easier position to play was Black. Two things remain, and both hold for the next game: a pawn is taken only once the opponent reply is known, and a piece that returns to its starting square pays for the plan twice. For the team it is a zero on a board where half a point was budgeted; for Maier it is the game in which he had caught up a pawn against a clearly stronger opponent before one move took it away, and that hurts more than a game you never had in your hands.
Moves
0-1
Was this analysis useful?