Analysis
The game in detail
GM Adrien Demuth (2513) vs IM Evgeny Degtiarev (2358) · ½-½
Board 2, ASK Réti vs SG Riehen · English Opening, Agincourt Defence (A13) · 90 minutes for 40 moves, then 30 minutes, plus 30 seconds per move
By Bogner AI Coach AI Coach . This analysis was written by a Bogner Chess AI coach.
Replay the game on LichessBoard two, ASK Réti against SG Riehen, round eight, all five matches of the round in one hall in Geneva. Across from Evgeny Degtiarev sits Adrien Demuth, grandmaster, 2513, a hundred and fifty-five points above him, and Degtiarev has Black. After seven rounds Riehen are second with twelve match points and Réti fourth with ten, and on seven of the eight boards Réti are the lower-rated side. Four and a half board points win the match. On board two a half point is not part of that arithmetic, it is one the other seven do not have to make up.
It became a half point, after thirty-six moves. For sixteen of them Degtiarev was clearly worse, and the game turned on one move by Demuth that rescued a piece.
Twenty-two minutes for 9...Bd6
: the pawn goes past instead of being propped up with or waiting with . Almost nobody at this level picks the push, and it is the best move in the position. From to not one black move loses anything, and after the game is level.
is the first move that develops nothing, and Demuth gets a route for it: heading for b5. After the same manoeuvre arrives, only with the king already safe. is the best move and costs twenty-two minutes, with 1:02:01 left after it, and sends the bishop straight back to b8.
After ten moves Demuth has 1:14:53 and stands about three quarters of a pawn better, and nothing has happened yet. A waiting move costs nothing as long as the opponent has nothing to improve; here he had the route Na3 and b5, and the half hour Degtiarev spent on nine moves went into a bishop that ends up back on b8.
GM Adrien Demuth (2513)
IM Evgeny Degtiarev (2358)
15...Bxb5, the trade almost everyone makes
is the break the whole white set-up has been aiming at, and is the right answer to it, the best move on the board: the bishop attacks the knight on b5 and Black keeps the pressure on c5. Demuth takes eighteen minutes and plays , with 40:09 left after it. He does not answer the attack on his knight because he does not have to: the pawn on c4 defends b5.
is a mistake, and it is not a question of move order. Black gives up the bishop for the knight, and the white pawn arrives on b5 for it: the chain b5 and c5 takes the air out of the black queenside, White keeps both bishops, and Black gets nothing back. The deficit grows from a good pawn to a good pawn and a half, which is a lot for one trade.
was right: the pawn comes back, material is level, and the deficit stays at about a pawn. Almost nobody at Degtiarev’s level picks that move, while the trade on b5 is one of the two most common answers there. That makes human and not correct. Before trading off a defended knight, ask where the pawn that defends it ends up.
GM Adrien Demuth (2513)
IM Evgeny Degtiarev (2358)
The exchange for nothing: 17...Nc2
, the knight move played in fourteen seconds: the knight from b4 attacks both rooks, a1 and e3, and one of them falls. covers a1, and collects the other. was a shade more accurate, a quarter of a pawn, and the difference is that the bishop ends up on e3 rather than the pawn. Demuth did not find it, and it did not cost him much.
The exchange changes nothing about the position. After White is a good pawn and a half better, because the pawns on b5 and c5 hold the black queenside down and because the bishop on b8 and the rook on a8 take no part. Practically it changes a lot: Black has two rooks and therefore something to work with, and in this position the clocks read 33:32 for White and 39:15 for Black.
costs fifteen minutes forty-six, with 23:59 left after it, and is the best move. asks the knight again at once, and is worth as much as , the difference is taste. After the white rook is on the seventh rank. Material is not an advantage: win the exchange and make the opponent’s pawns strong doing it, and you have traded rather than won.
GM Adrien Demuth (2513)
IM Evgeny Degtiarev (2358)
The pawn on a3 and the knight that pays for it
From move 21 Degtiarev plays the only plan the position still allows: . The pawn goes as far as it gets and the rook sits behind it. is worth as much as , and are the best moves on the board, and Demuth answers exactly right with , which was more than a pawn better than anything else.
costs seven minutes forty-eight and leaves 7:55 on the clock, and it is the best move again. What follows is a calculation and not a sacrifice: . The knight disappears for two pawns, and what is left is a passed pawn on a3 with nothing but a bishop in front of it. Objectively was a good half pawn better, and objectively Black was lost anyway. Practically it was the one way to put something in front of the opponent that he can get wrong.
costs Demuth six minutes and leaves him 3:56, and from here both players are under five minutes. is not the best move, was a good half pawn better, and it is still the move that saved the game: after , one of two legal moves, Black has nothing but rooks left, and rooks are what you can trade into a draw. When you are worse, trade off the pieces the opponent needs to win.
GM Adrien Demuth (2513)
IM Evgeny Degtiarev (2358)
31.Bb3, and the passed pawn gets through
White has exactly one move here that wins the game, and it is not the bishop: . His own passed pawn is faster than the black one, and it ties up both black rooks: , two bishops and a knight against a rook and two pawns. The bishop on a2 can be left to its fate: leaves White with a bishop and a knight against three pawns, which is won.
goes onto the board after two minutes thirty-nine, with 2:08 left, and it is the move that tips the game over. The piece is saved, it just no longer stands in front of the pawn. attacks it again and clears a2, and that is all Black needs: . One minute eighteen for , three minutes two for with 1:10 left after it, and from here it is no longer a grandmaster against an international master, it is a rook and four pawns against a rook and four pawns.
After the draw was agreed, four moves before the time control, with 1:59 against 1:54. When a piece holds up an enemy passed pawn, that piece must not be rescued: it is not standing there as material, it is standing there as a bolt. Demuth ignored the attack on his knight on move 15 and got the game out of it, and answered the attack on his bishop on move 31 and gave the game away with it.
GM Adrien Demuth (2513)
IM Evgeny Degtiarev (2358)
Verdict
A half point on board two against a grandmaster rated a hundred and fifty-five points higher, and one nobody had put into this match’s arithmetic. Both halves of it stay honest: was a mistake and cost half a pawn, and the exchange Degtiarev won two moves later changed nothing about the position. What came after it is what wins points: and , the only plan the position still had, the knight for two pawns so that the pawn on a3 stays alive, and from move 29 to the end not one move that loses anything. Demuth played thirty strong moves, and were the best on the board, and on move 31 he did not find the one move that wins; that happens on four minutes, and he had nothing to spare. For the second time in two rounds Degtiarev got an objectively lost game back, and where he handed it over again in round 7, this time he kept it. The learning: the pawn that does not fall decides the game, and the piece that holds it up must not be rescued. For Degtiarev this is a half point out of a position that had not been holdable since move 15, and for Réti it is one of the four and a half that win the match.
Moves
½-½
Was this analysis useful?