Analysis
The game in detail
GM Sebastian Bogner (SUI, 2542) vs GM Markus Ragger (AUT, 2573) · ½-½
Board 1, ASK Réti vs SG Riehen · Italian Game, Two Knights Defence with d3 (C55) · 90 minutes for 40 moves, then 30 minutes, plus 30 seconds per move
By Bogner AI Coach AI Coach . This analysis was written by a Bogner Chess AI coach.
Replay the game on LichessBoard one, ASK Réti against SG Riehen, round eight, played in Geneva. Across the board sits Markus Ragger, grandmaster, 2573, thirty-one points higher on the list. Riehen are second in the table, Réti fourth, and this is the direct duel between them, so what this board is supposed to bring the team is settled before the first move. Half a point with White against this opponent is the number the other seven boards can count on, and as in round 7 Sebastian Bogner sits on board one with White against a higher rated grandmaster.
It became an Italian Game with d3, no theoretical battle, and it gave White more than a quiet afternoon: about a pawn of advantage after twenty moves, a pawn and a half after Black’s twenty-fourth. What became of it was settled by one capture on move 35, played with 1 minute 25 on the clock.
Twelve minutes for 20.c4
Italian with , and with the game is out of the books. Ragger sets up with the bishop on g7, White puts the pieces where they belong and waits. offers the exchange of bishops, and is the best move, although nearly half the field puts the knight on d5 here. After Black has doubled pawns on e5 and e6. The f-file opens four moves later: , and White rooks stand on that file until move 36.
is played by one player in ten here; most push through in the centre with d4 or put the queen on b3. The knight offers itself to the knight on h5, and if Black takes, White gets the file. Sebastian spends freely on this build-up: four thinks of more than nine minutes in the first twenty moves, eleven of them on .
is the first move that costs something, about half a pawn. was the move, because from there the queen supports the c3-c4 push White makes two moves later anyway. Ragger had the answer on the board twice: hits the bishop on c5 and holds White down to half a pawn. He plays instead, and the half pawn is back. The same thing a move later: is only the third best move, was better, and after there would again be only half a pawn left. comes instead, and White is back to a whole one.
is the longest think Sebastian takes in this game, twelve minutes five, with 22 minutes left after the move. The pawn steps alongside the black one on d4 and fixes it there, and it prepares c4-c5, the move that opens the c-file four moves later. Thirty-one points of difference on the rating list, and after twenty moves the player with fewer of them has a pawn of advantage and the open file. Read from the other side, that is a lesson about the pawn on a5: against a6 it is a standing invitation to b7-b6, and in positions like this one that move is not something for later but the first candidate on every move. Ragger had it twice and did not play it twice, and both times it was worth half a pawn.
GM Markus Ragger (AUT, 2573)
GM Sebastian Bogner (SUI, 2542)
24.c5, and 24...Rfd8
With Ragger attacks the bishop on c5, and is the move, almost half a pawn clear of everything else: White gives bishop for bishop and keeps the c5 square for the rooks, which stand there six moves later. Then it gets loose. costs close to half a pawn, was the move, and gives the half pawn back. trades the queens and costs a quarter, with queens on was stronger. None of this is an error; these are the quarter and half pawns that travel back and forth in a long game.
Almost nobody finds here, and it is the only move that keeps more than half a pawn: the pawn walks into the capture, and the rook fetches it back. , White stands about three quarters of a pawn better, and the black king is on its way to the centre, where it belongs in an endgame.
Ragger thinks for twelve minutes ten, the longest think of the game by either player, and plays . That is the error on the other side. After the rook has to recapture passively, , with the c-file belongs to White, and three quarters of a pawn have turned into a pawn and a half. Objectively was the move. In practical terms the one played is understandable: dxc5 hands a pawn over voluntarily and plants a white rook on c5, and after an hour and a half of defending, holding the structure together looks safer. It is not. A pawn you cannot hold is one you give up, as long as you get something that stays: here it would have been two tempi for the king.
GM Markus Ragger (AUT, 2573)
GM Sebastian Bogner (SUI, 2542)
Fourteen minutes between move 26 and move 34
is the best move. and occupy the file and cost a quarter to a third of a pawn each: the kingside was stronger, with the g4-g5 push behind it, breaking up the pawns in front of the black king. is not the strongest move either, a quarter behind : brings the knight to e5 via c4, and that is worth more than a pawn which White takes straight back with .
What it costs is time. Between move 26 and move 34 Sebastian spends fourteen minutes and Ragger nine, which leaves 2 minutes 52 against 8 minutes 11; alone costs four minutes forty-one. The position holds all the way through that stretch, about a pawn, now and then a little more. What drains away is half a pawn and nearly all of the thinking time.
is the only move that keeps the advantage, almost a pawn clear of and , and it arrives after seven seconds. Coming that fast, it means he had seen the position. After the rook goes back with check, , and with that this position stands on the board for the second time. A third pass through it would be a draw. If you buy air in time trouble with checks, you need the move that comes afterwards before you start: the repetition is free twice, and the third time the game is over.
GM Markus Ragger (AUT, 2573)
GM Sebastian Bogner (SUI, 2542)
35.Nxc6, with 1 minute 25 on the clock
On move 35, is the best move again, and again about half a pawn clear of everything else. is what gets played, after one minute fifty-seven.
The move is a miscalculation and it costs the whole advantage. : at the end of the sequence the black king takes the rook on f7, and that is the point of it. Material is level, White still wins the d4 pawn back with , and in the rook ending that comes out of it the pawn is worth nothing.
The exchange was right, just one move early. , and now it works: the rook stands on g6 instead of f7, the king cannot take it because the knight on c6 attacks the rook on b8 from there at the same time, and Black has to capture with the pawn. At the end of that line White is about a pawn better with both rooks on the board.
Objectively is the move that settled the game: about a pawn of advantage before it, and after it a rook ending with nothing in it for either side. In practical terms it looks different. 1 minute 25 after the move, five moves to the time control, and a liquidation in which nothing can go wrong any more is a decision one understands in that situation. It is not even the human move. At this level two players in five play here, a third play , and one in twenty takes; what decided this moment was the clock. Before a sequence of captures you count more than the material: you count what recaptures last, because a king that takes with a tempo at the end turns a good exchange into an empty one.
GM Markus Ragger (AUT, 2573)
GM Sebastian Bogner (SUI, 2542)
The rook ending, and 53.d5
puts White a pawn up, and after , taken in passing, he stays there. The pawn is worth nothing: from here to the last move the ending is level. Both get through the time control narrowly, White with 1 minute 51 after his fortieth, Ragger with exactly one minute after his, and on move 42 the extra half hour arrives for both.
Ragger collects the kingside pawns with and , White takes the queenside one with , and what is left is rook and three pawns against rook and three pawns. Sebastian spends the half hour as well: 28 minutes 25 on his clock after , 1 minute 50 after , while Ragger finishes the game with 11 minutes 13. Time goes where the decisions are, and in this ending they were on White’s side of the board.
costs five minutes thirty-five and closes the game out: , and the pawn on e5 is a passed pawn. It runs to e7, the white rook on h7 attacks the pawn on h6, and the fact that Black has two pawns against one after no longer changes anything. Ragger takes on d5, which is correct; anyone who interposes a check here instead loses. The draw is agreed after . A rook ending is not decided by the number of pawns but by the passed pawn and the rook that has to stop it: two extra pawns are nothing while your own rook is tied to one that wants to run.
GM Markus Ragger (AUT, 2573)
GM Sebastian Bogner (SUI, 2542)
Verdict
Half a point with White on board one against a grandmaster rated 2573 is a usable result for the team, and it is his third draw in eight rounds. For him there was more in it: he stood better from move 17 to move 34, a pawn and a half after Ragger’s twenty-fourth, and move 35 left nothing of that. As in round 7 the position was worth more than the result, and it is the same point as there, seen from the other side: there the break was missing, here the liquidation came one move too early. The learning fits into two sentences. Before a sequence of captures, what counts is not the material but who recaptures last and with a tempo. And if you buy air in time trouble with repetitions, you need the next move before the repetition runs out. Credit to Ragger for what he took out of it: he stood worse for eighteen moves, he found the right answer on move 53 where a wrong one would have lost, and he finished with more time on the clock than his opponent. What goes into the match record is a half point on board one in a match lost 3.5 to 4.5; a whole point on this board would have levelled it, and until move 35 it was there.
Moves
½-½
Was this analysis useful?